070720 Enough with the Happy Talk, OK? Beyond the Curve: Dr. Peter Lurie’s COVID-19 Blog

Enough with the Happy Talk, OK?

Beyond the Curve: Dr. Peter Lurie’s COVID-19 Blog

Reprinted by permission of Dr. Peter Lurie and I endorse his message and encourage you to sign up for his COVID-19 blog.

June 30, 2020

SHARE THIS https://action.cspinet.org/page/59909/subscribe/1?ea.tracking.id=0vv8d2km

See all Beyond the Curve posts.

To hear the administration’s recent pronouncements, you’d think it was all going swimmingly. Vice President Mike Pence took to the always welcoming opinion pages of the Wall Street Journal last week to declare that “we are winning the fight against the invisible enemy.” On Friday, he maintained that states are reopening “safely and responsibly,” though at an event in Dallas on Sunday even he had to retreat from the he-man posture by donning a mask. Not to be outdone, the President proclaimed in an interview last Wednesday that the virus is “dying out.”

Are you following the same pandemic I am? Mine looks like this (from the New York Times):

A rising infection curve and text saying

Does this look like a virus that is dying out? Does this look like victory to you?

Predictably, the administration came armed with an evidence-free explanation: the problem is more testing, not more virus, tempting the President to flirt with “slow[ing] the testing down.” Right. And if we remove climate change information from the EPA’s website, as the administration has done, the earth’s temperature will stop climbing.

Sure, there might be some increased case detection due to (finally) increased testing. But how does that explain the increasing proportion of tests that are turning up positive? (That metric should go down as less risky people come forward to be tested when more tests became available.) Or the increases in hospitalizations in some states that also have rising case numbers?

The fact is we are witnessing a disaster in both domestic and global terms.

Let’s start at home, using data from the Washington Post’s website. First, let’s look at the toll to date in each state. Unlike a lot of the data you see presented, let’s look at the data adjusted for underlying population sizes. If the data are presented this way, the top ten most affected states and the associated numbers of deaths look like this, as of June 29:

Top 10 states by infection rate

These ten states, which account for about 40% of all cases in the U.S. to date, are primarily concentrated in the Northeast.

But if we look instead at where the epidemic is growing fastest, measured by the percentage of all cases in each state that have occurred since June 23, we see a very different picture:

Top 10 states by percentage of cases since 6/23/2020

There is no overlap between the states with the historically largest overall outbreaks and those where it is now growing fastest. So as the initial epidemic is on the wane, controlled largely by the adoption of social distancing, hand-washing, and masks, it is being  succeeded by a new epidemic in parts of the country that were largely spared at first. The top ten fastest growing states account for about 20% of all cases to date. Expect that to grow. (Admittedly, it is easier to have a high percentage increase if your state was relatively spared in the initial phase of the epidemic, but the overall point still holds. The two most heavily affected states overall, New York and New Jersey, together totaled 5,383 cases since June 23, compared to 42,838 cases during that same period in Florida alone.)

Now let’s turn to the global situation. Tragically, it’s even worse. Here’s the latest global count of daily coronavirus cases (again from the New York Times).

A rising global infection curve with text saying

Absolutely frightening. Next, we’ll take a similar approach to analyzing the data as we did for the U.S., using data from the Worldometers website. Let’s start by recognizing that the U.S. and Brazil, two countries whose leaders responded with a toxic melange of denialism and data-free policies, represent almost two-fifths of cases worldwide to date, even though they hold only 7% of the world’s inhabitants. But the toll on the ground is best measured in per capita cases and deaths, again all through June 29:

Top 10 countries by cases per million people

Although the U.S. is heavily affected, the countries with the highest per capita rates (among those countries with populations of at least five million) are actually Chile and Peru. We’ll focus on the case rates, because some of the death rates are suspiciously low (hello Oman, hello Singapore).

We wanted to calculate the percentage of cases that are recent the way we did for the U.S., but the data on the most recent cases appear to be erratically reported internationally. Instead, we’ll confine ourselves to the countries with the largest numbers of recent cases (June 28) and report results for them only (some countries, none large, are missing data for June 28). The data look like this:

Top 10 countries by new cases

From this analysis, we learn that there are still more new cases per day in the U.S. than anywhere else in the world (a few days ago, the U.S. was second behind Brazil), although the largest number of new per capita cases is in Chile, followed by the U.S. and Brazil. This is where the burden of current infections is hitting hardest.

Unless you’re the Trump administration or the Bolsonaro administration in Brazil, there is no way to sugarcoat this. This pandemic is raging in new parts of the U.S. and in a growing number of countries around the world.

Let’s try to end on as optimistic a note as the data permit. What has been done so far to stem the tide has been successful in states like New York and New Jersey and countries like Italy and France, which don’t even appear in these data. This means we know what to do to slow the spread of the virus: governments must face the facts, engage in straight talk with their populations, and implement policies derived from evidence-based science. Until there is a vaccine, that is our only hope.TOPIC: Beyond the CurveCOVID-19

Peter Lurie

Peter Lurie

Peter Lurie, M.D., M.P.H. is President of CSPI.  Previously, Lurie was the Associate Commissioner for Public Health Strategy and Analysis at the Food and Drug Administration, where he worked on antimicrobial resistance, transparency, caffeinated beverages, arsenic in rice, fish consumption by pregnant and nursing women, expanded access to investigational drugs, and prescription drug abuse.  Prior to that, he was Deputy Director of Public Citizen’s Health Research Group, where he addressed drug and device issues, coauthored the organization’s Worst Pills, Best Pills consumer guide to medications, and led efforts to reduce worker exposure to hexavalent chromium and beryllium.  Earlier, as a faculty member at the University of California, San Francisco and the University of Michigan, he studied needle exchange programs, ethical aspects of mother-to-infant HIV transmission studies, and other HIV policy issues domestically and abroad.CONTACT INFO: 

Contact us at cspinews@cspinet.org with questions, ideas, or suggested topics.

2 thoughts on “070720 Enough with the Happy Talk, OK? Beyond the Curve: Dr. Peter Lurie’s COVID-19 Blog

  1. FIRST……..I RARELY LISTENED TO A MOST BIASED EX GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEE AND THEIR SOURCES…..ESPECIALLY THE NEW YORK (SOVIET) TIMES……..ONE HAS TO BUY INTO THE ACCURACY OF THESE REPORTS WHICH EVERY SANE PERSON ON THIS PLANET KNOWS IS DOCTORED BEYOND BELIEF…….PERSONALLY OF THE THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE I KNOW IN MY STATE AND OTHERS….I KNOW OF NOT ONE CASE LET ALONE ONE DEATH…….AND OF COURSE A SOCIALIST POINT Of VIEW IS ALWAYS ,…..ALWAYS….NEGATIVE……GET A LIFE DR LURIE…AND LIFE WILL GET BETTER FOR YOU…..EVERYONE I KNOW IS DOING JUST FINE…..remember also…..Liberty should never be sacrificed for security…….

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.